This page reproduces proposal text and published results preserved from Snapshot. It reflects the archive capture below.
Archive capture completed:
Published voting information
State at capture
closed
Voting type
approval
Created
2022-10-29 04:32:00 UTC
Voting opened
2022-10-29 04:30:23 UTC
Voting closed
2022-11-05 04:30:23 UTC
Snapshot block
15851338
Participation score
11176.801215780322
Published quorum
4717
Quorum type
default
Recorded ballots
266
Published choice scores
Choice
Score
Scale with NO ETH (12 ETH)
6719.259431598815
Flat number of ETH per validator
4966.213557715146
Scale with Protocol ETH (36 ETH)
3496.2066803316334
Remove LEB8s from Atlas
124.48329819845412
Abstain
57.92701233816682
Preserved proposal text
Original text, including Markdown notation. Linked content is not reproduced here.
This vote is to specify the max effective stake for LEB8s.
Here's a table showing how the proposed strategies look for the minipool sizes that will be available in Atlas:
| **Option Name** | **Max effective RPL stake** | **Minipool16** (min-max effective) | **LEB8** (min-max effective) |
|----------------------------------|------------------------------|---------------------------------------|---------------------------------------|
| Scale with NO ETH | 1.5*NO_ETH | 1.6-24 | 2.4-12 |
| Flat number of ETH per validator | 24 | 1.6-24 | 2.4-24 |
| Scale with Protocol ETH | 1.5*Protocol_ETH | 1.6-24 | 2.4-36 |
Note that while this vote is meant to establish our design moving forward, there are other ideas being actively pursued. As with the rest of RP - the DAO may vote for further changes in the future as it sees fit.
This vote uses _approval voting_. This means you can vote for one or more options, with each selection getting your full voting power. The intent is for voters to select all choices that they approve of (if multiple), instead of limiting them to their top preference.
### Further Reading
- Full LEB proposal: [RPIP-8](https://github.com/Valdorff/RPIPs/blob/max_collateral_leb8/RPIPs/RPIP-8.md)
- [An NO ETH centered proposal, with reasoning](https://dao.rocketpool.net/t/max-collateral-for-lebs/1166?u=valdorff)
- [A protocol ETH centered proposal, with reasoning](https://dao.rocketpool.net/t/an-argument-in-favor-of-protocol-eth/1208)
- A flat number of ETH per validator is proposed here as a compromise position between the above two